Difference between revisions of "Rodin Performances"

From Event-B
Jump to navigationJump to search
imported>Nicolas
m (→‎Results: added an empty table for config2 upto 2.2 results)
imported>Nicolas
 
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 240: Line 240:
 
|
 
|
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| s
+
| 18.2 s
−
| s
+
| 21.8 s
−
| s
+
| 33.7 s
−
| s
+
| 30.7 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Parser
 
| Parser
 
|
 
|
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| s
+
| 17.9 s
−
| s
+
| 38.9 s
−
| s
+
| 16.9 s
−
| s
+
| 11.1 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models only
 
| Builder / models only
 
| [[#Cruise Control 0.5.0]]
 
| [[#Cruise Control 0.5.0]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| s
+
| 124.2 s
−
| s
+
| 206.7 s
−
| s
+
| 32.5 s
−
| s
+
| 33.1 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
 
| [[#Cruise Control 0.5.0]]
 
| [[#Cruise Control 0.5.0]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| s ( / 2911 POs)
+
| 356.7 s (1550 / 2911 POs)
−
| s ( / 2911 POs)
+
| 633.4 s (1550 / 2911 POs)
−
| s ( / 2911 POs)
+
| 505.5 s (1574 / 2911 POs)
−
| s
+
| 477.2 s (1574 / 2911 POs)
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models + proofs
 
| Builder / models + proofs
 
| [[#Cruise Control 0.5.0]]
 
| [[#Cruise Control 0.5.0]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| s
+
| 120.7 s
−
| s
+
| 204.9 s
−
| s
+
| 126.5 s
−
| s
+
| 111.9 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models only
 
| Builder / models only
−
| [[#Systerel Project]]
+
| [[#Cars on a Bridge]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
|  
+
| 1913 ms
−
| s
+
| 2401 ms
−
| s
+
| 839 ms
−
| s
+
| 855 ms
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
−
| [[#Systerel Project]]
+
| [[#Cars on a Bridge]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
|  
+
| 3934 ms (237 / 237 POs)
−
| s ( / 1360 POs)
+
| 3888 ms (237 / 237 POs)
−
| s ( / 1360 POs)
+
| 3413 ms (237 / 237 POs)
−
| s
+
| 2536 ms (237 / 237 POs)
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models + proofs
 
| Builder / models + proofs
−
| [[#Systerel Project]]
+
| [[#Cars on a Bridge]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
|  
+
| 2688 ms
−
| s
+
| 3287 ms
−
| s
+
| 2050 ms
−
| s
+
| 1982 ms
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models only
 
| Builder / models only
−
| [[#Cars on a Bridge]]
+
| [[#Systerel Project]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| ms
+
|  
−
| ms
+
| 89.7 s
−
| ms
+
| 9.8 s
−
| ms
+
| 10.1 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
−
| [[#Cars on a Bridge]]
+
| [[#Systerel Project]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| ms (237 / 237 POs)
+
|  
−
| ms (237 / 237 POs)
+
| 185.8 s (1218 / 1360 POs)
−
| ms (237 / 237 POs)
+
| 167.2 s (1218 / 1360 POs)
−
|  ms
+
| 165.9 s (1218 / 1360 POs)
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models + proofs
 
| Builder / models + proofs
−
| [[#Cars on a Bridge]]
+
| [[#Systerel Project]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
−
| ms
+
|  
−
| ms
+
| 147.0 s
−
| ms
+
| 106.9 s
−
| ms
+
| 82.3 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models only
 
| Builder / models only
Line 329: Line 329:
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
|  
 
|  
−
| s
+
| 195.6 s
−
| s
+
| 49.1 s
−
| s
+
| 53.1 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
Line 337: Line 337:
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
|  
 
|  
−
| s ( / 1360 POs)
+
| 377.7 s (2381 / 2595 POs)
−
| s ( / 1360 POs)
+
| 271.6 s (2381 / 2595 POs)
−
| s
+
| 308.8 s (2381 / 2595 POs)
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models + proofs
 
| Builder / models + proofs
Line 345: Line 345:
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
|  
 
|  
−
| s
+
| 231.2 s
−
| s
+
| 148.0 s
−
| s
+
| 141.0 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models only
 
| Builder / models only
−
| [[#XCore Extension]]
+
| [[#XCore Encoding]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
|  
 
|  
−
| s
+
| 210.0 s
−
| s
+
| 54.1 s
−
| s
+
| 56.2 s
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
 
| Builder + Auto Prover / models only
−
| [[#XCore Extension]]
+
| [[#XCore Encoding]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
|  
 
|  
−
| s ( / 1360 POs)
+
| 367.3 s (1209 / 1370 POs)
−
| s ( / 1360 POs)
+
| 243.5 s (1209 / 1370 POs)
−
| s
+
| 262.3 s (1209 / 1370 POs)
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Builder / models + proofs
 
| Builder / models + proofs
−
| [[#XCore Extension]]
+
| [[#XCore Encoding]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
| [[#Configuration 2]]
 
|  
 
|  
−
| s
+
| 230.9 s
−
| s
+
| 146.6 s
−
| s
+
| 150.4 s
 
|}
 
|}
  

Latest revision as of 08:43, 17 June 2011

Performance measures for the Rodin Platform.

Configurations

Configuration 1

System:

  • Intel Pentium Dual Core E2180 (2* 2 GHz)
  • 2 Go RAM

OS:

  • Ubuntu 10.10
  • linux kernel 2.6.35-25
  • GNOME 2.32.0

Java:

  • Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.6.0_22-b04)
  • Java HotSpot(TM) Server VM (build 17.1-b03, mixed mode)
  • VM arguments
    • -Xms40m
    • -Xmx1200m

Eclipse:

  • Helios (3.6.1)
  • JUnit 4.8.1

Configuration 2

System:

  • Intel Pentium Dual Core E2180 (2* 2 GHz)
  • 2 Go RAM

OS:

  • Ubuntu 11.04
  • linux kernel 2.6.38-9
  • GNOME 2.32.1

Java:

  • Java(TM) SE Runtime Environment (build 1.6.0_24-b07)
  • Java HotSpot(TM) Server VM (build 19.1-b02, mixed mode)
  • VM arguments
    • -Xms40m
    • -Xmx1200m

Eclipse:

  • Helios (3.6.2)
  • JUnit 4.8.1


Benchmark Projects

Cruise Control 0.5.0

  • 7 Contexts
  • 49 Machines
  • 2911 POs

Cars on a Bridge

Taken from Jean-Raymond Abrial's book "Modeling in Event-B"

  • 3 Contexts
  • 4 Machines
  • 237 POs

Systerel Project

  • 9 Contexts
  • 14 Machines
  • 927 POs

XCore

  • 62 Contexts
  • 50 Machines
  • 2595 POs

XCore Encoding

  • 45 Contexts
  • 15 Machines
  • 1370 POs

Protocol

A measurement is launched using the JUnit plug-in fr.systerel.perf.tests. Tests are run from a freshly launched eclipse as only running user application, in UI thread, with an empty workbench.

Launch Configuration must include exactly the following plug-ins:

  • fr.systerel.perf.tests
  • org.eventb.core
  • org.eventb.core.seqprover
  • org.eventb.core.ast
  • org.rodinp.core

Every measurement starts with the build of a fake project intended to load all needed classes (extra time of more than 10 seconds has been observed for build). Class loading is intended to be optimised separately.

Verify that 1200 Mo are free when tests are ready for launch.

Tests

Lexer

A base string is made of all standard Event-B Mathematical Language symbols, separated from each other with a space character.

The string to lex is made of the concatenation of 100000 times the base string.

The lexer is called 10 times on the string to lex.

Parser

The parser is called on formulae covering all Event-B operators:

  • 43 predicates
  • 140 expressions
  • 7 assignments
  • 1 big predicate (1750 characters)

The parsing is repeated 4000 times.

Builder / models only

The project initially contains only model files (contexts and machines). It is built with auto provers turned off.

Builder + Auto Prover / models only

The project initially contains only model files (contexts and machines). It is built with auto provers turned on.

Builder / models + proofs

The project initially contains models and proofs (contexts, machines, proofs). It is built with auto provers turned off.


Results

The following results are means of 3 successive measures.

Measures
Test Applied to Configuration Rodin 1.3 Rodin 2.0 Rodin 2.1
Lexer #Configuration 1 19.0 s 21.4 s 35.6 s
Parser #Configuration 1 17.1 s 39.3 s 17.2 s
Builder / models only #Cruise Control 0.5.0 #Configuration 1 119.6 s 211.0 s 30.9 s
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #Cruise Control 0.5.0 #Configuration 1 351.5 s (1550 / 2911 POs) 641.9 s (1550 / 2911 POs) 484.5 s (1574 / 2911 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #Cruise Control 0.5.0 #Configuration 1 108.6 s 199.1 s 123.3 s
Builder / models only #Cars on a Bridge #Configuration 1 2060 ms 2524 ms 995 ms
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #Cars on a Bridge #Configuration 1 4388 ms (237 / 237 POs) 4320 ms (237 / 237 POs) 3466 ms (237 / 237 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #Cars on a Bridge #Configuration 1 2843 ms 3360 ms 2238 ms
Builder / models only #Systerel Project #Configuration 1 88.7 s 11.2 s
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #Systerel Project #Configuration 1 185.7 s (1218 / 1360 POs) 162.3 s (1218 / 1360 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #Systerel Project #Configuration 1 149.9 s 109.4 s
Measures
Test Applied to Configuration Rodin 1.3 Rodin 2.0 Rodin 2.1 Rodin 2.2
Lexer #Configuration 2 18.2 s 21.8 s 33.7 s 30.7 s
Parser #Configuration 2 17.9 s 38.9 s 16.9 s 11.1 s
Builder / models only #Cruise Control 0.5.0 #Configuration 2 124.2 s 206.7 s 32.5 s 33.1 s
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #Cruise Control 0.5.0 #Configuration 2 356.7 s (1550 / 2911 POs) 633.4 s (1550 / 2911 POs) 505.5 s (1574 / 2911 POs) 477.2 s (1574 / 2911 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #Cruise Control 0.5.0 #Configuration 2 120.7 s 204.9 s 126.5 s 111.9 s
Builder / models only #Cars on a Bridge #Configuration 2 1913 ms 2401 ms 839 ms 855 ms
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #Cars on a Bridge #Configuration 2 3934 ms (237 / 237 POs) 3888 ms (237 / 237 POs) 3413 ms (237 / 237 POs) 2536 ms (237 / 237 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #Cars on a Bridge #Configuration 2 2688 ms 3287 ms 2050 ms 1982 ms
Builder / models only #Systerel Project #Configuration 2 89.7 s 9.8 s 10.1 s
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #Systerel Project #Configuration 2 185.8 s (1218 / 1360 POs) 167.2 s (1218 / 1360 POs) 165.9 s (1218 / 1360 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #Systerel Project #Configuration 2 147.0 s 106.9 s 82.3 s
Builder / models only #XCore #Configuration 2 195.6 s 49.1 s 53.1 s
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #XCore #Configuration 2 377.7 s (2381 / 2595 POs) 271.6 s (2381 / 2595 POs) 308.8 s (2381 / 2595 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #XCore #Configuration 2 231.2 s 148.0 s 141.0 s
Builder / models only #XCore Encoding #Configuration 2 210.0 s 54.1 s 56.2 s
Builder + Auto Prover / models only #XCore Encoding #Configuration 2 367.3 s (1209 / 1370 POs) 243.5 s (1209 / 1370 POs) 262.3 s (1209 / 1370 POs)
Builder / models + proofs #XCore Encoding #Configuration 2 230.9 s 146.6 s 150.4 s


The figure below presents and sums up the values of the table above:

Rodin Performances Core perf fullv3.png

Test Builder = SC + POG + POM, no proof attempt is performed.

Retrieved from ‘https://wiki.event-b.org/index.php?title=Rodin_Performances&oldid=7290’